Reviews of Liberty Tree Tavern Lunch
Read prices, menu items, and more
Menus at Liberty Tree Tavern
Reviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 03/03/2021
Rating: (1) Not Recommended
After having many happy memories of meals at the Liberty Tree Tavern, prior to leaving on our trip, I checked the lunch menu, it was as I remembered and we looked forward to our meal. When we approached the CM to be seated, we were taken in to the Tavern lobby as before, then we were told, to follow the CM back outside to another building "right next door" and the CM mentioned the family style meal they were offering. We were led to the Diamond Horseshoe! Not the same thing. And the "family style meal" was not a choice but the ONLY choice. We were stunned. What a disappointment! The food was brought on a platter, pot roast, turkey and roast pork, mashed potatoes, green beans, all together! A side bowl of macaroni and cheese and some rolls are what I remember. Dry, bland, the Dole whip we had in the morning was way better than anything we had at our "family-style lunch."
Pros:
The waiter was nice.Cons:
It was the worst meal I've had in a Disney restaurant, and the bill for the two of us, (no alcohol) with tip was $99.07! And that meal was the end of our Disney trip. We left a day early.Reviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 03/05/2021
Rating: (2) Not Recommended
Waiter ignored us, had to remind him many times when he came by table what we needed. Took forever to get food, drink and food refills. Also took at least 20 minutes to get check back. Waiter seemed to fill others rolls, drinks, etc. a lot more quickly than for us. Too bad he didn't know we usually leave at least a 50% tip. He got far less. We always eat here when we go to the Magic Kingdom but not next time.
Pros:
Dessert was goodCons:
Waiter, time it takes to get food, price for such lousy serviceReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 04/24/2020
Rating: (2) Not Recommended
We were looking forward to this reservation for lunch but were vary disappointed. I had to pick several rotten pieces of lettuce out of my salad and the chicken had a weird airplane chicken kind of texture. They really skimped on the rest of the toppings too. I don't recommend this restaurant.
Pros:
It's in The Magic KingdomCons:
The food and the service wasn't very good eitherReviewed by SandiK Review Date: 12/04/2017
Rating: (2) Not Recommended
Liberty Tree Tavern has been our MK go to restaurant for years. We love the turkey dinner that was available on the regular menu. That is no longer the case with the turkey being part of a 3 course $35 lunch. Once I discovered this the day of the reservation that was credit card guaranteed, we went begrudgingly hoping there was something on the menu we would like. I ordered the fish and chips which arrived soggy and greasy. Frozen fish made at home would have been far better than this tasteless, greasy lump on my plate. The cole slaw was swimming in vinegar and really unpleasant. Hubby had the pot roast which he liked and I ended up eating his green beans and my french fries for lunch. So disappointing. Liberty Tree is now on the Never Again list.
Pros:
Fast ServiceCons:
Menu changes and greasy soggy fishReviewed by yanyans Review Date: 12/19/2016
Rating: (2) Not Recommended
now have a shared platter menu which is not good
very poor choice even though its all you can eat. we waited a long time for it to arrive and had to ask for more then waited again
only 3 choices on the al la carte menu and discouraged from ordering from this menu
now very poor value for money and the food poorly cooked in comparison to previous visits
Pros:
noneCons:
changed menu, poor value, lack of choiceReviewed by Lanmon Review Date: 12/08/2016
Rating: (2) Recommended
We ate here in October and were looking forward very excited to have their delicious pot roast and vegetarian sandwich for lunch 12/3. Had we known the menu had changed we would have canceled our reservations. The menu is an all you can eat buffet for $35 and a few a la carte items. There are no vegetarian dishes unless you do not have shrimp or chicken on the salad. Will not be returning to this restaurant.
Pros:
AtmosphereCons:
Changed menu, removal of delicious itemsReviewed by snovak Review Date: 11/11/2016
Rating: (2) Not Recommended
We ate here Oct. 26th for lunch, and found out they had just changed their menu that day. Very little choice of entrees, but they were now offering the all you can eat Pilgrims Feast that they serve at dinner time. My sister and I decided to go with that, seeing the place was busy and we had it before and knew that it was very good. Our waitress brought us our drinks, rolls and salad within 10 minutes and that's where it started to go all wrong. She disappeared! A large table(8) next to us had requested some refills on their dinner and she didn't return for 25 min, as she walked past us she said our lunch was "right behind her. We weren't sure what that meant because another 25 minutes went by that we didn't see her and finally a waiter brought out our lunch. Our reservation was at 1:20, we got seated at 1:30 and didn't leave until 3:30. The food was good, but this is the same thing that is served every night on their dinner menu so I still don't know what the hold up was. It would have been nice if our waitress or someone would have taken the time to stop at our table and let us know what was going on instead of feeling like we were just plain forgotten about. For that reason, I won't go back.
Pros:
AtmoshpereCons:
wait timeReviewed by MoBach Review Date: 03/20/2020
Rating: (4) Not Recommended
Not crazy about the restaurant itself, very outdated inside. Food just ok.
Pros:
Location is good, right by Haunted Mansion and Hall of Presidents.Cons:
Outdated restaurant and mediocre food.Reviewed by Pearlman88 Review Date: 11/12/2014
Rating: (4) Not Recommended
We had lunch at this restaurant. My meal was not fully warm and our server had too many tables to cover. The kids liked their meal, though (kids meals come with a red, white, and blue sprinkled sundae).
Pros:
LocationCons:
Lukewarn food, indifferent serviceReviewed by Daniellep93 Review Date: 06/15/2013
Rating: (4) Recommended
We eat here every time we visit at least once if not twice (we have visited 6 times) and is on my family's must do list, in fact it is usually our first and last meal in Disney World. We are used to great service and food from this restaurant but sadly not the case this time. This time it was obvious that our food was sitting and was not fresh. Within about 5 minutes of ordering our food was at our table. The gravy was thick and gel like on the turkey and the pot roast had no visible gravy, although this was quickly remedied by the server bringing out a gravy boat. This time we were so rushed that we had a full sit down meal in 30 minutes. Not sure if we will return after this, we probably will and just hope it was an off day.
