Reviews of Captain’s Grille Lunch/Dinner
Reviewed by dsnyak5 Review Date: 05/22/2013
Rating: (4) Recommended
My husband and I dined here twice during our recent stay May 9-14. We were staying at the Beach Club, so it was very convenient.
Lunch. Never again. Poor service, and the food was just awful. Husband got the burger and clam chowder. I got the tuna sandwich and clam chowder combo. I got my meal, and was half way through it before his meal came, and we had to flag down the waitress to ask for it. Let me warn you against the clam chowder. The worst we have ever experienced. We both regretted it all day and into the evening.
Breakfast. We both had the buffet. A wide assortment of choices, all seemed fresh, we made only a couple of disappointing choices. However, there were no plain bread/toast choices. No white, no wheat, no bagels, no English muffins. (The husband likes toast with his eggs). I would go back for breakfast, but for the money, I think I will skip the buffet and just order something from the menu.
Pros:
—Cons:
—Reviewed by Lighthouse Review Date: 06/13/2013
Rating: (6) Recommended
We ate here for dinner on a recent stay at Beach Club.
Friendly staff, comfortable seating
Menu limited in choices. Two of us at table ordered steak. Steak was tasty but tough and hard to cut.. We had not been given steak knives so asked for sharper knives. Ten minutes later waiter brought steak knives explaining that he had to go to Yachtsman's Steakhouse to "borrow knives" from them. By that time we were done eating rest of meal. Perhaps the restaurant should invest in new utensils!
Pros:
Convenient location Yacht & Beach ClubCons:
Limited menuReviewed by nrymut Review Date: 06/16/2013
Rating: (10) Recommended
Had a great dinner here in June. Flavors were well developed in both of our dishes. Service was nicely done. Restaurant was not crowded and tables are well spaced.
Pros:
food, serviceCons:
noneReviewed by mawdryn Review Date: 07/09/2013
Rating: (10) Recommended
My family of 6 enjoyed dinner here on July 2. I was very hesitant after some of the negative reviews, but I have to say this was probably my favorite meal of the entire 6 day trip.
We were seated promptly at our 6 o'clock reservation time and the service was excellent. Our waiter, Matt was wonderful. Ask for him if you dine here. He made sure all of our needs were met. He was also very friendly and chatted up my entire family.
We enjoyed crab cakes, clam chowder (best I have EVER had), crab legs, NY strips, fish of the day and pasta.
Pros:
Food and ServiceCons:
NoneReviewed by nursenita Review Date: 11/29/2013
Rating: (5) Recommended
Just not our type of food, limited menu, limited sides.
Pros:
good drinksCons:
limited menuReviewed by rebelbuddhist Review Date: 01/05/2014
Rating: (9) Recommended
We were sad that the crab cakes were off the menu when we were there in December after Christmas. But the other seafood appetizers, scallops, clam chowder, were good. The steak entree was surprisingly enjoyable since this is not a steak house. Our steaks were prepared well just as we ordered. This is a less expensive alternative to the signature restaurants that offers a fine meal for the price. The atmosphere is peaceful and the service was excellent from the sign-in podium to the servers.
Pros:
Good food and friendly serviceCons:
—Reviewed by mawdryn Review Date: 03/18/2014
Rating: (10) Recommended
My husband and I ate here on March 8th for his birthday lunch. We were on the deluxe dining plan, so I had the crab cake appetizer and he had the soup special. My entree was the lobster roll and it was overflowing with lobster meat. It was delicious. My husband had the fish and chips, which were equally yummy. For dessert, I had the Braeburn apple buckle, and my husband had the chocolate cake. We were also presented with a complimentary glass of champagne to celebrate my husband's birthday, and the waitress brought him a balloon with Mickey weights. This place is a hidden gem, and I highly recommend it. I have now dined her for lunch and dinner.
Pros:
Menu Offerings, and ServiceCons:
NONEReviewed by lisakb22 Review Date: 04/01/2014
Rating: (9) Recommended
Great place! Good service and the crab legs amazing and plentiful! Weird crab cake, no breading and not fried, more like warm crab salad.
Pros:
food and serviceCons:
crabcakeReviewed by GinaDD Review Date: 08/27/2014
Rating: (9) Recommended
We enjoyed lunch here. We had a large group but the meal was still prompt. I had the lobster sandwich . It was good, but a little rich. DH and DS each ordered a Manhattan clam chowder special that was delicious . It will ruin me for any other clam chowder. We had a late lunch so the room was not overcrowded and service attentive.
Pros:
Interesting menuCons:
—Reviewed by Disney_Dreamz Review Date: 11/26/2014
Rating: (9) Recommended
I ate here on 11-15-2014 and loved it.
I had the crab cakes and my mom had the Chef's pasta creation. For dessert my mom had the Seasonal Fruit cobbler (which was apple), and i had the cake. Everything was REALLY good.
Service was really good as well.
