Reviews of Diamond Horseshoe – Frontierland – Open Seasonally
Reviewed by 45stoutjay Review Date: 04/06/2020
Rating: (3) Not Recommended
This is not a good place to eat at all. There are so many other places to eat in the Magic Kingdom than Diamond Horseshoe
Pros:
The theming and restaurant itselfCons:
The foodReviewed by MarLL55 Review Date: 04/18/2019
Rating: (4) Not Recommended
What to say, what to say? Our waiter was very nice and very attentive. From that it went downhill. If the food that we were served was the food that was on the menu when you looked under Diamond Horseshoe on line-then it might have been ok. I was expecting a low key rootin tootin saloon. Not to be.
Pros:
Server was great -the piano only played one time.Cons:
Food needs worked onReviewed by Bruce Review Date: 03/04/2019
Rating: (2) Not Recommended
Horrible food & service
Pros:
its cuteCons:
food, service , dirtyReviewed by Quinniebear Review Date: 02/28/2015
Rating: (1) Not Recommended
Visited on February 27. Ordered a brisket sandwich with fresh chips. The carved pork was dry and tasted terrible. Sandwich covered in a horrible onion sauce. The fresh chips turned out to be a bag of lays because "the kitchen can't keep up." No apologies. My husband's portabella salad was passable. Both of us said it was worse meal ever on Disney property.
Pros:
Inside seating good serviceCons:
Poor quality foodReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 11/01/2021
Rating: (8) Recommended
Very good! I don’t understand the mixed reviews. My 20 and 15 year old daughters enjoyed it very much. The pot roast and dressing were our favorites (I would have been proud to have cooked them myself), and the dessert that we thought we didn’t want was delicious. We are so much that it was our only meal for the day, so it ended up being a great value, too. Cute place, great food!
Pros:
All you care to eat Good foodCons:
Small tablesReviewed by Anonymous Review Date: 05/20/2021
Rating: (9) Recommended
I ate here in 2018 with my husband and it was fantastic! So fantastic he demanded we go back in 2019. The food is great and family style. There is corn bread, brisket, mac and cheese, I do not get the hate this place gets. Maybe bbq isn't for everyone, fair enough.
Pros:
Good bbq, great atmosphereCons:
Open seasonallyReviewed by SuzQ92 Review Date: 05/17/2021
Rating: (9) Recommended
We ate here on a Halloween Party night in 2019 and really enjoyed the BBQ food. We were actually disappointed that we couldn’t eat more at this all-you-can-eat restaurant because we ate so much from the first serving that we were full! The atmosphere is nostalgic and fun, making you feel as if you’ve been transported back to the early days of Walt Disney World.
Pros:
The Mac n Cheese was particularly good! Loved the all-you-can-eat BBQ food and atmosphere.Cons:
Only open seasonally.Reviewed by lcg Review Date: 05/13/2020
Rating: (8) Recommended
We enjoyed a nice mid - day Thanksgiving meal here. It is served family style. The food was great, however not the most unique menu Disney has to offer.
Pros:
Had a great interaction with Cast MembersCons:
If family style does not fit your party - most likely not the place for youReviewed by MaryW Review Date: 04/17/2019
Rating: (7) Recommended
We enjoyed the meal here. It’s served family style. You can often get a seat here instead of Liberty Tree when the park is busy. The salad and cornbread is very good.
Pros:
The watermelon slushee drink is very refreshing on a hot day.Cons:
Limited menuReviewed by Chench Review Date: 01/25/2019
Rating: (10) Recommended
I can't say enough about our experience to the Diamond Horseshoe! After a long day of rides, walking, shows, walking, sun and... did I mention WALKING? we were tired and hungry!
The food was delicious and though I wouldn't say perfect, we also weren't expecting to be sitting down to a gourmet meal. We were sitting down to a family style, all you can eat table of some real good saloon grub. The price wasn't cheap, but the amount of food well made up for it.
Everyone loved the pulled pork and chick the most. The cornbread was served warm and sweet. Drinks were cold. The service was perfect, quick and not too intrusive but always available. We found the place at this link https://www.visitflorida.com/en-us/eat-drink/family-guide-restaurants-disney-magic-kingdom.html which lists a bunch of Magic Kingdom restaurants.
The saloon atmosphere was also great. Everyone loved the look of the place! This is definitely the kind of place to take a group of hungry Disney explorers. Overdoing it though may slow you down for the rest of your visit! We were all wanting a nap after our meal. 🙂
