AEN banner

Main

Mike's Mailbag Archives

February 23, 2008

Of Surprises, Marathons, American Cousins, and Treasures

I kept telling myself to put together a mailbag blog entry and kept forgetting but forget no more. Here is the first of what I hope are many opportunities for me to share with all of you some of the letters I receive from time to time. I’d like to share them all with you and it was most difficult choosing which to share…perhaps that’s what has taken me so long to getting around doing a mailbag blog entry.

Anyway, here are some I hope you will enjoy.


Surprise! Surprise

From Jennifer:

Was catching up on your marathon posts, as I haven't had time to read your blog lately and imagine my surprise when I came across your picture of the people in the Soarin' queue guiding the bird through the forest. No, it wasn't me, but my brother! He's the one in the gray Illinois State t-shirt. He was visiting Epcot that day by himself, the only free day he had while attending an Army National Guard conference at a nearby resort.

Thanks for making him just a little bit more famous and for giving me a good laugh for the day :)

Love the blog and love WDW Today. Keep up the great work.

Jennifer

LOL...thanks Jennifer...here's the picture Jennifer speaks of.


Soarin_Kiosk_lean.jpg

There’s a Reason for Everything

From Leslie:

Dear Mike,

I just returned from my first "official attempt" at a 1/2 marathon and I am very pleased to share that it was this year’s Donald. WOW, Disney sure makes sure that this experience is one to remember!

I wanted to send you a heartfelt THANK YOU for the marathon information that you posted on January 5th... It made this experience so much easier and calmed my nerves on what to expect... I did not finish, as I knew that I would not, but your words of wisdom within this blog helped me to start the race, give it my all, and have a sense of grace about when it was time to stop.

I am sure that you receive tons of email like this, but earlier this year I suffered a hip injury that required surgery and during this surgery they found a genetic defect that required repair as well. I did not lose hope about the Donald, but as I am only 11 weeks out of surgery knew that my chances of finishing were slim to none. So many emotions... frustration as I was ready, disappointment that I was not there for my walking buddy, and fear that I would be picked up before the first pacing point...

I am very proud to say that I started this race, kept up the pace as best I could, and made it through the Magic Kingdom with the help of many well meaning fellow walkers. I surpassed my own goals! Thanks for the words of wisdom and encouragement!

Leslie Mack

Leslie the only regret I have after reading this note from you is that I did not get a chance to see you at the race and give you a hug for your tremendous attitude and effort. You are an inspriation to us all.

Perseverance Pays Off!

From Janelle:

Congratulations on the Race, Mike!

I religiously read every entry you wrote for the year leading up to the race and I thank you for all your advice and words of wisdom.

For my first race...ever...I, too, entered as walking wounded. I had 3 rounds of pneumonia since Oct. and had taken my coaches advice to sit it out. But something came over me at the Expo and I thought, "I can definitely make to MK."

I kept plugging away and did finish (a time I'm not proud of, but finish I did. I hope you will keep filling us with race thoughts as I'll need it in the coming year...I've taken leave of my senses and am going Goofy next year. Hope to see you out there!

Janelle

Janelle...I think that certain "something" that came over you at the Expo was your confidence in yourself to do this. Nice job.

Congrats to Claudia!

From Claudia:

Hey Mike,

I've just been catching up after coming back from WDW and the marathon weekend. Wasn't that an awesome experience? It was my first and I really, really loved it. I wish I lived closer and then I could do this more often but as it is, I won't really be able to get back to WDW for a marathon in a while - transatlantic flights are a bit costly!

I've also been listening to your discussion on WDW radio (I'm about 1/3 of the way through the podcast!) and it's been a great way to re-live the experience, even though I did the full and you guys all did the half. I finished with such a buzz from the whole thing that even now, more than two weeks after the event, I still can't stop talking to everyone about it. It was magical and yes, surreal...

I wanted to write to you and thank you. It was your blog, along a few others, that inspired me last year to sign up for this race and I don't regret it. Sure, I had my bad days when training didn't go very well or when my confidence was shaken and I didn't think I would finish. It was all totally worth it for the sheer experience of running at the World and getting that amazing medal. So thank you - I wouldn't have done it if it wasn't for your enthusiasm.

Also, this is the only exercise that I've stuck to longer than a few months and I'm actually starting to enjoy it. So I will keep running (I have the whole kit now too, so better use it) and look forward to the XX marathon weekend when I plan to go again and get myself another one of those special edition medals.

Congratulations and thanks again,

Claudia (in UK)

Way to go Claudia. Thank you for the kind words and sharing your experience.


My American Cousin

From Joan:

I have just read your article about the American Adventure. I too love the attraction. I visit Disneyworld at least once a year. The reason I'm writing to you is because my cousin posed for the father in the "two brothers" segment.

I am attaching the picture of my cousin standing next to his animatronics figure. I gave a copy of the picture to one of the men at the American Adventure. I hope you enjoy it.

Sincerely,

Joan Neumann

Author’s Note” Unfortunately Joan’s cousin passed away a few years ago but here is a photo of her cousin standing next to his animatronics counterpart.

Robert_E_McCarthy_as_WDW_HOP_character1.jpg

Disney Magic!

From Nicole:

Reading Mike Scopa's article "The Unheralded Treasures of Walt Disney World" spoke of Streetmosphere at Disney Hollywood Studios. One of my favorite memories of my dad comes from a trip I took with my family when I was 10 (over 15 years ago).

My mom and I were talking a few steps behind my dad when a mime walked next to him and took his hand. Thinking it was my mom he started a conversation but got no response. When he finally looked at his "wife" he was shocked to see the mime and even jumped a little while my mom and I were laughing.

My dad was a good sport and every time we reminded him of what happened he would smile and laugh a little himself.

Thanks Mike for bring back his happy memory... can't wait to tell my mom!

Nicole

Vacations serve many purposes Nicole and one purpose is to make memories. thanks for sharing.

Special Moments

From Holly:

I just read the "Unheralded Treasures" article. What a great term. We all have had those special moments which is what keeps us coming back. The article reminded me of our Unheralded Treasure.

One HOT June afternoon we (2 men, 3 ladies and 2 children 6 and 4) took the launch over to Tom Sawyer Island. The magic happened when the men chased the kids around the island the 3 ladies relaxed in the rocking chairs, in the shade on the boat dock with cool lemonade.

It doesn't get any better than that.

Holly

Y'know Holly, I know there is an undiscovered unheralded treasure waiting for everyone on every trip....one reason why we keep going back.

The Little Things

From Sally:

My absolute favorite unheralded treasure is hearing the lovely French music that plays on the lower path of the walkway between the resorts around Crescent Lake and the International Gateway.

It seems like almost everyone is in a rush to get to World Showcase, and takes the much wider "overpass." Perhaps the same music plays up there, but I've never heard it!

My second favorite involves the French pavilion itself - being one of the first patrons of the Boulangerie Patisserie in the morning sitting outside at the little tables and feeding croissant crumbs to the birds.

It's the little things, isn't it?

Sally

Yes Sally it's the little things or as we see in the next letter from Virginal...it's the details.

Here's a picture I took from International Gateway one morning before WS opened...that's the bridge to France.

Crescent_LAKE.jpg

Don’t Forget the Details

From Virginia:

Reading your article in All Ears Newsletter made me think those are the special things about Disney that cause us to make the trek several times a year, the thing that most people don't understand. I want to add one to your list.

Last October while I was waiting for Spectromagic to begin, I was eating a snack on a side street off Main Street. I heard a terrible sounding piano, then a women yelling. Then I heard tap dancing. It took me a minute to figure it out.

Across the street, a window read something out Piano Lessons and/or Tap Dance Lessons, and that was the commotion I heard.

Those are the details that make Disney special to me; most people are too busy running to the next attraction to take the time to appreciate the small things.

Thanks for reliving the magic,

Virginia Pierce

Virginia, thanks for reminding me about some of the Magic on Main Street USA.

Thanks to everyone who took the time and effort to drop me a note. I appreciate feedback and any thoughts you may want to toss my way.

2009 Marathon Weekend Alert

For those of you who are planning to participate in any of the races during the 2009 Disney Marathon Weekend I encourage you to register ASAP with special emphasis to those planning to do the very popular Walt Disney World Half-Marathon.

That race is at least 85% full.

Go to the Walt Disney World Half-Marathon Registration Page to register.

March 18, 2008

M’s Are Wild: Mike's Mailbag

Mike's Mailbag

Before they get lost in the shuffle let me share some recently received emails.

Most of them touch upon my recent discussion on Disney Withdrawal and Disney Saturation:

First up, Heidi Potenza:

It has been 1 whole month since we got back from our trip to Disney. Mike's blog brought a smile to my face because we too have had this very discussion about "too much of a good thing." We started out visiting WDW every couple years when we could afford to. We have now made it an annual pilgrimage with our kids who truly look forward to it as much as we do!

I agree with Mike's observations about how your appreciation changes for different things the more you visit. We just spent 8 days park hopping, as well as the Pirates & Princesses Party one night. The last night of our vacation, we stayed until 10 p.m. even though we had to be at the Orlando airport for a 6 a.m. flight just to get every last little bit of Disney magic in until next time!

I will know that I have had enough Disney when I walk into the Magic Kingdom, and stand there gazing down Main Street at that beautiful castle, and not have tears streaming down my face.

Then perhaps we will have a serious discussion about saturation!!

Heidi

castle_02.jpg

Thanks for the email Heidi. My tears usually appear on the last night of a trip when I’m leaving Magic Kingdom. Once I hit the Emporium area I cannot turn back to look at the castle.


From Jon Simon:

I fully comprehend what Mike refers to as saturation. I would rather use a different term, because I think saturation equals a lack of appreciation.

More appropriate is commonplace. He is used to going and lacks the excitement the vast majority of people face going and the withdrawal he describes.

Two members of my family recently went to WDW and I felt a form of withdrawal every day they were there. It was the first time I was unable to accompany them.

Every time I hear the Year of a Million Dreams theme I get chills. My wife who just returned does not share this feeling.

My withdrawal was made a little easier while they were away because Mr. Scopa made me feel wonderful by calling me while he met up with my son while at Epcot.

Jon

Thanks for the note Jon. I had a great time chatting with your son Ben. The only thing better would have been if you were there to take part in the conversation.

We called you from the top of the hill in the picture below...right near International Gateway.

International_Gateway_hill.jpg


From Philip DeLuccia (who I happen to know just celebrated a birthday…Happy Birthday Phil)

Mike, I just finished reading your blog about Saturation Point. My family and I have been down there every other year since 1994, but recently my wife and I are trying to go once a year. We find ourselves visiting the newest attractions (or recently upgraded), then we take in our favorites as time permits. We've also tried out of the ordinary outings like renting a boat from Old Key West and traveling along the waterways to The Marketplace, Port Orleans, and back. We've also tried Para-sailing behind The Contemporary and are planning on going to Discovery Cove this coming January 2009 (weather permitting).

I have to say that just being in the parks gives me a feeling of fulfillment and pleasure, whether I get on an attraction or not. Evelyn (my wife) is looking forward to upcoming races and I look forward just to be in The World. We experienced Mickey's Not so Scary this past October as well as the Tower of Terror 13K (if you remember, Evelyn and I chatted with you while waiting for the beginning of the race). I'm going to pick up Annual Passes for the two of us, since we'll be going down this coming October for 5 days, 10 days in January, and another 5 days in October 2009. I figured Oct 2009 would be at the beginning of the month, so Evelyn can run the Race for the Taste. I enjoyed talking to you this past October, and, after reading your blogs and listening to your opinions on the podcasts, I find that we have much in common. I totally agree with you regarding not letting my children roam around a Theme park by themselves. I don't care if it's WDW or not, I trust my children, but I don't trust everyone else. Our children are our most valuable possessions and I know I'd die if anything happened to mine. Hopefully we'll get to chat again while in Florida (maybe Jan 2009). Until then, I'll keep reading your blogs and listening to your podcast.

Keep Well,

Phil DeLuccia

Phil is referring to a recent discussion on the WDWTODAY podcast in which the panelists debated on whether or not they would allow a thirteen year old and his eight year old brother to roam in the Magic Kingdom while the parents enjoyed a quiet meal at California Grill.

By the way Phil, my wife and I and two of our cast member friends spent one afternoon on a boat and went to see Old Key West. Here is what it looked like as we arrived at OKW.

OKW1.jpg

From Jenny:

I found your blog on saturation to be extremely true. Walt Disney World definitely means many different things to everyone. Like your early years, we can only manage family trips every other year and are working towards our biggest one yet and the anticipation and planning are only part of the fun. We have celebrated all (honeymoon, birthdays, Christmas, New Years, & soon anniversary) at the World and the saturation has not yet set in and I hope that it never does. For us, it truly is THE HAPPIEST PLACE ON EARTH!

Your Blog is great, keep it up!!

Thank you for the kind words Jenny. I think annual trips work well for most folks because of the excitement of planning and anticipation of every trip and more importantly, annual trips keep everything fresh and that saturation point well off the radar.


Here’s a note from a fellow AllEars colleague

From Glo
Mike,

Just wanted to say that I loved your blog segment about withdrawal/saturation.

Like you, when we had family, living in Michigan, our trips were about every 18 months. Once the kids were gone, just Gary and I went every year in January ...same awful withdrawal!
Then we moved to Miami in 1998 and went about once a month. In 2001 we bought a small home in Kissimmee just so we could go more often and stay longer.

Guess what! Saturation ;-) We still love WDW and always look forward to going, but, just as you said, now it's the atmosphere, it's the people-watching, it's the beauty of the landscaping and architecture. It's simply strolling down the rose walk and photographing particularly beautiful blossoms.

...and virtually the only time we do attractions is when we have friends, family or the grandkids visit.

Now about those fireworks! You may skip them sometimes, but that's one thing I can't do without LOL

Glo

Glo, your note triggered a thought. I have another friend who moved from Michigan to Florida and he lives about an hour from WDW. I’m not sure where he is on the saturation scale but one of the things he said his family misses is the resort atmosphere. There is no need for them to stay at the resorts and that, he said, is part of the whole WDW experience....

...and I'm with you all the way on the fireworks! Have you ever watched Wishes from the California Grill?

CG_Wishes.jpg


From a fellow Red Sox fan

From Kathleen:
Dear Mike:

I just returned from the World and at your advice, I checked out Spaceship Earth. I can offer a mixed review. I enjoyed the new narrative, but was underwhelmed by even the computer room.

I prefer by far the recent Pirates and Haunted Mansion rehabs! My kids (10, 8, and 8) LOVED the quiz at the end. As I think Deb may have mentioned in an All Ears review, I concur that a memorable song like "Tomorrow's Child" would enhance the experience. Nice but not a "must see."

I will be able to return April 17-23 (I NEVER get 2 trips a year--this is HUGE) and can't wait!!!
Thanks for asking my opinion. Wishing you and your family many trips to the World full of moments in the "zone."

Good luck to your knees and the Red Sox this spring!!

Kathleen

Thanks Kathleen. Everyone needs to see the new Spaceship Earth for themselves. There have been some amazing improvements to this attraction. I somehow get the feeling however that there is still more to do.

Go Sox!


Here’s one from a New England neighbor Virginia Pierce

Being a fellow New Englander from RI, I must start off by saying "Go Sox!"

Reading your article in All Ears Newsletter made me think those are the special things about Disney that cause us to make the trek several times a year, the thing that most people don't understand. I want to add one to your list.

Last October while I was waiting for Spectromagic to begin, I was eating a snack on a side street off Main Street. I heard a terrible sounding piano, then a women yelling. Then I heard tap dancing. It took me a minute to figure it out. Across the street, a window read something out Piano Lessons and/or Tap Dance Lessons, and that was the commotion I heard.

Those are the details that make Disney special to me; most people are too busy running to the next attraction to take the time to appreciate the small things.

Thanks for reliving the magic,
Virginia Pierce

Virginia I am so glad you sent me that email because it points out how rushing around a theme park prevents some guests from noticing the details that go into the design and development of each area of the theme parks. Once you noticed these details you develop a deeper appreciation for what Walt Disney World offers its guests. I’m always discovering these subtle touches.

I discovered something last Summer while riding the steamboat at Magic Kingdom. Have you ever noticed this dog watching this fish jump out of the water?

Fish%20and%20Dog.jpg


From Jennifer

Awesome blog post! What great observations! I love your point that although you don't take in as many attractions, you enjoy the atmosphere and just being there without the stress!

A short but very insightful email from Jennifer. I hope everyone sees Jennifer’s point here. A trip to WDW is supposed to relieve stress not add to it and sometimes you have to relax and not worry about making every attraction you can on every day of your trip.


From Nikki

Mike,

I totally loved your article "Disney Withdrawal vs. Disney Saturation." It spoke directly to my husband and me. We recently returned from our latest Disney vacation in Feb of 08. We had the discussion about how Disney is changing for us. We no longer have the same excitement about the same things as we once had! The examples in your article directly described us! We no longer get the excitement out of being at a park for the rope drop. We would rather sleep in and take it easy. We have found other "attractions" at Disney World that appeal to us!

Keep up the great writing!

Nikki

Very interesting comments Nikki…although the theme park excitement isn’t there for you anymore there is still something that keeps bringing you back to WDW. This is yet another testimony that there is something for everyone at Walt Disney World....like...

Aloha_Isle_Sign.jpg


From Shea:

Mike I could not agree with you more. My wife and I go to Disney about 1 X a month. We live in West Palm Beach. Since the new dog has arrived we have not been there since December. We go at the end of March for the day.

However some of our best attractions are now people watching. It’s really great and we try to spend a little time doing just that. When we go back for the day it will be just for a few hours with lunch at our favorite restaurant Le Cellier.

Keep up the great work,

Shea

Shea, I love people watching. I could sit on a bench all day and watch guests walk by. I play a game and try to identify those guests who I feel are first time visitors and for those who are WDW veterans. I mostly enjoy watching the children. For those who know me you obviously realize that I can never get enough of Le Cellier.

Finally, from George, a note regarding the WDW Marathon weekend:

Mike,

The Marathoning with Mickey post was fantastic! I always enjoy your trip reports and reading how your trip is going. The pictures of an almost empty Epcot were jaw-dropping!

I had another question for you. I tore my meniscus and my ACL in a mixed-martial arts class in 2004. I would love to participate in something like the half-marathon, but I am afraid the damage I would do to my knee would be unbearable. I do focus on working out my quads and hamstrings (along with all of the other muscles in the legs) so I don't hurt my knee further.

I know this is rather ambiguous, but do you have any thoughts on how someone like me could participate? Are there volunteer positions along the race? I would love to be part of it!

Thanks!

George

Well George, obviously the best thing to do is to consult with your doctor before deciding whether or not you could participate in the half-marathon.

Everyone is different and what works for one person may not work for another.

Consult with your doctor to discuss what your limitations are rather than risk more damage to your knee. You never know, there could be some therapy available to help you.

There are quite a few people who love volunterring for Marathon Weekend. You should find information on how to volunteer by going to the Walt Disney World Marathon Weekend Home Page as we get closer to the event.

Thanks to everyone for sending their thoughts along and sharing them with me and everyone else.

July 21, 2008

Mailbag: No Kidding Around!

Mailbag: No Kidding Around!

This is a special mailbag edition of “The View from Scopa Towers” in which Michelle Scribner-MacLean I answer some of the many emails we received regarding our “No Kidding Around” blogs.

To refresh your memory, here are the links to Part 1 and Part 2.

Following each letter you’ll first find Michelle’s comments, followed by my comments.

Many readers supported the idea of having a trip to WDW enhance their educational experiences.

Karen’s daughter integrated her study of Germany with her trip:

“We ate lunch at the Biergarten and interviewed cast members about their home country and gathered info from the menus, shops any anything else we could find. She also needed audio-visual aids, so we bought a t-shirt with the German flag on it and some cookies made in Germany. (She wore the t-shirt and passed out cookies to the class) We also picked up an EPCOT guide map (written) in German to use in her presentation.”

Michelle’s comments:

While the idea of turning your vacation into an extended field trip may not appeal to everyone, Karen and her family clearly sought out the details that make each of the countries at EPCOT so interesting. The food and the ambiance were designed to entertain, but also to teach visitors about the countries. Karen made the most of her child’s out-of-school experience by doing some preplanning.

Mike’s comments:

I think that regardless of where you travel it will and should result in somewhat of an educational experience. WDW is no exception. The term “edutainment” was coined to describe what EPCOT has to offer…but I think it is also suitable for all the theme parks. There are some things you just cannot teach in the classroom.

Several teachers jumped on-board and had their say. Larry, who is from a family of teachers, speaks for many educators wrote:

“…we suggest a temporary tutor or relative who can catch up the child. If they do take the work with them, and complete it and come back with a question, that’s great--we'll help. But many, many vacationing kids who take the work with them do NOT even start it, much less complete it. We gladly work with kids after school that have been out due to illness or other legitimate (approved/excused) reason. Even though we are tremendous Disney fans, we don't approve of leaving school for a trip.”

Michelle’s comments:

Larry makes an important point. If you’re planning on taking your children out of school, it is a good idea to contact the teacher to find out what work needs to be completed or made-up, but parents need to follow through. Missing school to go to WDW doesn’t mean that the work missed disappears. Making up the work might be considered “part of the deal” – and parents should hold up their part of the bargain by ensuring work that their child missed is turned in.

Mike’s comment:

Let’s face it, life is a partnership and early on our partners are our parents. If these partners don’t pull their weight then there will be consequences. I think the most discouraging aspect of this is that these parents miss out on teaching their kids a lesson on responsibility and also unfortunately are making a comment to their children that perhaps school is not that important.

A cadre of parents wrote to express their appreciation for teachers who were supportive and accommodating teachers. They felt that many educators supported their decision to take their children out school to go to WDW.

Reader Stacey agreed, saying, “Many teachers are more than willing to work with you so that you can take a nice family vacation and also make it a learning experience.”

Michelle’s comments:

Trying to find quality family time is something with which many parents struggle. Some parents supported the idea of taking children out of school because they have work schedules that do not mesh with school vacations, while others believe that taking their kids out of school to go to WDW only enhanced their family experience.

Mike’s comments:

It’s that partnership thing again….the child-parent-teacher partnership can make this a wonderful experience and in today’s society everyone’s schedule is just plain nuts. I know when my children were young there were piano lessons, singing lessons, dance lessons, baseball, soccer, basketball, and oh yes I was playing softball and coaching so rarely were those family days. When we went to WDW it was for two weeks at a time…the best two weeks of the year because we did everything together….priceless….but those two weeks were during the summer when our schedules were open.

Here are some other comments:

Pat mentioned that she and her family decided that taking kids out of school worked better when they were younger, but not as they grew older. She goes on to say, “…family time is an extremely rare commodity these days. The times we spent at Disney World are great memories for our family just spending together. We now have two college graduates, so I guess our Disney Trips did nothing to hurt their academic progress.”

Deb believed that her experience with her granddaughter was worth the missed school time:
“Her wonderful experience with us, at Disney, far outweighed any loss from being in school during that week. She still talks about her experiences every single time we get together. Life is about the memories we create with our loved ones.”

Finally, reader Marguerite broke Mike’s heart by asking…
“What exactly is a "Dole Whip?”


Michelle’s final thoughts on the topic (for now):

Regardless of whether or not parents decide to take their students out of school, planning a trip to WDW should be a team effort. Parents, children, and teachers should discuss the pros and cons of missing school, how feasible it will be to make up work, and weigh the benefits of a trip to WDW against the potential difficulties of making up school work. There’s no right or wrong here – every family has to make the decision that is best for them.

Mike’s final thoughts on the topic (for now):

The only right answer here is what is most appropriate for the individual child. Some children will thrive with an opportunity to enhance his/her education outside the classroom. A WDW vacation will do so. Others may struggle and face “catch up” on the return.

What is important here is that any decision should not be made in a vacuum but after some discussion among parent, teacher, and child. Remember, the focus should be on the child and a WDW vacation that requires taking the child out of school, if done right, will return many dividends.

We have received so many emails on this topic that it became very difficult to determine which ones to include in the mailbag; each and every email was worthy. We felt it best to include those which most exemplify the majority of opinions expressed.

We thank those of you who took the time to write and send your thoughts on this subject.

Michelle & Mike


November 24, 2008

The $1,696 Mailbag - Part 1

I’ve received many responses from that $1,696 commercial blog I had written a few weeks back. Thanks to everyone who took the time to write and I apologize if I have not gotten back to all of you.

I thought I would put together a mailbag blog filled with some of the notes I’ve received. Here is Part 1 of the Mailbag!

Barbie writes:

“Thanks for your entry about the Magic Your Way commercials. It's great to read a fair commentary on what is and is not included in a very non-critical presentation of facts. We love Disney and vacation there often - "we" are a family of four just as Disney defines it: 2 adults, 1 child, and 1 junior. We have found many ways to make our Disney vacations affordable, so that we can visit multiple times in a year. (We spent a weekend in February, 11 nights in May/June, and will spend 3 nights in December.) We often run into people we know when we visit - I don't know exactly how that happens, but it nearly always does - and when we compare resorts and/or vacation lengths, our friends often comment something like, "How can you afford it?" or "Wow, that's an expensive hotel, isn't it?" or "You must really take Disney World seriously." Well, we work hard to make it affordable and appreciate when all the costs of any particular element of the vacation are well-known to us. Thank you for helping other families know what they are getting into so that they, too, can enjoy and relax without the constant shock of more spending. (We usually end our vacations under budget, and that's the way we like it.)”

Barbie’s point is simple….we all need to work hard to make our vacations affordable. That means always being on the lookout for deals, discounts, and ways to slice expense here and there.


From Crista…

“I will agree on the cost from the commercials. I have a family of four. When we went to WDW the commercial "cost" was $1400. We had two adults, one 7 year old and one under the age of 2. We stayed at the Pop Century for 7 days and six nights. We did get the park hopper tickets and ate at one restaurant a day. We brought snacks or ate once a day at our hotel. We packed suitcases full of food including breakfast. We only drank water at the park and spent an average of $20 a day. We bought souvenirs almost everyday. And last but not least we flew to the Park and parked our car at our airport for the week. So in the end our cost for our vacation was $3432. Even if that seems like a lot, with the right planning it can be the vacation of a lifetime and I would do it all again. This was the first WDW trip for my husband and two boys. My husband felt like a little kid again. Priceless.”

Crista and her family made choices that helped them make their vacation affordable. Young families should take note of how Crista’s family saved money. There’s a bonus here…teaching the children some lessons on how to be frugal.


I was excited to read this from Chica…

“I was really interested when this post popped up on my feed-reader, as my GF and I are planning our first trip to Disney together right now. For a while, we thought we absolutely couldn't afford it, and we're not exactly the norm (no children) for a Disney Trip, but we crunched the numbers and figured out we could do it.

We're going December 14-20th, flying from Philadelphia and spending one day at each park, with a break one day for Downtown Disney and a movie.

Here's our budgeting:

Package from Disney - $1009.82
This Includes:
- 6 nights Pop Century Standard Room
- 4 days park admission (non park hopper)
- Disney Meal Plan for 6 nights (this was a special promotion that was emailed to us after we signed up for the mailing list)

Flight Round trip from Philadelphia - $365.00 for both (including all fees)

Alcohol and Tip money for expenses not covered by Meal Plan - $150.00

Souvenir money (including our Christmas present budget for friends/family/each other) $300 ($150 each)

Now, we can always guarantee some unexpected expense, so we've built in an extra $150 cushion into our budget

Grand total comes to $1975.00

Now, we like to over budget and have extra left-over. So we doubt we'll max out all our budgeted areas. We also plan to use the envelope system. 7 days, 7 envelopes ($50 for the first and last days, $100 every other day). No credit cards, no charging to the room. Only one envelope out of the safe on any given day. At the end of the day, whatever is left can get moved to the next day or later. But once you empty an envelope, you're done.

Now, for the experienced Disney traveler, our plan might not be ideal. But for two girls going on our first 'real' vacation together post college (because spring break doesn't count...), it's a pretty good plan with a reasonable budget. It works out to just about one paycheck for each of us.

I'll definitely agree that the Disney ads are a bit misleading and that if you're serious about budgeting, double the quoted Disney price is just about what your final cost would be.”

It does come down to choices and how you choose to best afford your vacation.

Chica, please look for me when you are in WDW. It just so happens that while you are there I’ll be there for Mousefest.


Amy talks about her family’s planning process…

“I just wanted to take a moment and say that for our family we find WDW to be a great value for our vacation dollars. We are preparing for our fourth trip and once again, we are really impressed with how affordable it is.

We are staying at a moderate resort (with a discount code) this time and paying out of pocket for the DDP for 8 nights. We don't do park hoppers - just base tickets because with enough days we just don't have the need to hop. All said, including airfare, this trip cost us LESS THAN $3000. Breaking that down for our family of 4 we are spending less than $100 per day for food, entertainment, lodging and transportation.

Our last trip we were on the free dining and we stayed at POP (which we LOVED) - that trip we were spent less than $50 per person per day.

We have a very basic theme park and water park here in the Kansas City area and you can't go to either of them for that little money when you factor in food, gas and admission. When you compare the cost to a trip to a family resort destination like Beaches (which we also LOVE) - WDW is about 1/2 the cost!!

I think that given the magic you are a part of and the memories you create, WDW provides a great bang for your buck. For families that are willing to look for discount codes, don't mind the value resorts and forgo park hopper options; there are very affordable options for planning a great WDW vacation!”

Hmmm, it seems one way most people are cutting costs is to forego that park-hopper option. At $53.25 per ticket, the savings can be significant for a family of four.


Jennifer also opts to not include the park hopper option…

“Mike,

Great comments on that promotion.

I think things like park hopper are not that big of a deal to leave off if you only get to the parks every few years. I know we skip the hopper option because we don't like to waste the additional travel time between parks. We get down there every 2 years or so and just set our own expectations that we'll do one a day and if we get done early (say on our second day at a park) we explore other resorts (free) or Downtown Disney, or our own resort.

The food too can be controlled if appetizers and dessert are left off. We eat almost entirely at table service for lunch and dinner as we use these times as our breaks from heat/being on our feet. We've been able to eat at table service restaurants for 25 per person or less 80% of the time and it usually works out to about the same or less than we would have spent a la carte at counter service.

Not ideal for everyone, I know, but I thought I'd concur that it can be done if people are serious about Disney AND serious about having to budget...

Keep up the great blog!! Jennifer”

Jennifer adds another great tip…forget the appetizers and desserts. They too can add up quickly. If you crave for something sweet there’s always a counter service somewhere offering a decent snack....like a Dole Whip.


icon_dole2.gif


Check back tomorrow for Part 2 of the Reader Mailbag on Disney's $1,696 Commercial!

November 25, 2008

The $1696 Mailbag - Part 2

Recently I blogged about Disney's Magic Your Way commercial.

Yesterday I shared Part 1 of the emails I received as a result of that blog.

Today I share with you Part 2 (and the final part) of your feedback. Thanks to everyone who wrote in!



Kelly draws a great analogy between putting together a WDW vacation and purchasing a car…

“Thank you, thank you, thank you for printing what I've been preaching for years. I go to Disney every other year; we usually stay for 10 nights and 11 days, park hopper/water park/more tickets for 9 days, dinning plan, at a value resort for $1249 a person. (If we're lucky, we sometimes get an upgrade for free - free dining plan or park hopper is free) I tell people how much my trip will cost and they flip out.

They can't figure out that it's like buying a car. You can get a standard car (basic ticket/value resort hotel) for around 16,000. But if you want leather interior (Deluxe hotel) it’s more. Or Satellite radio (dinning plan) a few more dollars. Chrome wheels (park hopper) its more. Lifetime extended warranty (no expiration of tickets) its more. So you can drive off the lot with a standard car for 16,000 or drive off the lot with all the extras for 36,000 or somewhere in between. Same with Disney you decide (standard - moderate - deluxe) but you will pay for your extras. You will have a great time at the standard level, so don't think you have to upgrade. You just need to sit down and decide what you can handle financially.”

Great note Kelly…wish I had thought of putting it that way.


Marc sees another car buying analogy…

“Hey Mike,

I look at the "$1696" just like the car commercials where you can buy a Honda for 15k. As they show a nice looking accord drive by the fine print at the bottom says Vehicle shown is 22k”


From Lesa…

“I never see comments on going cheap - and meaning it - from those of you experienced Disney visitors. We went last year for our first time. We drove in from Dallas (it was a beating, but a quarter of the cost to fly). Instead of spending our time standing in lines and eating in nice restaurants that would bore our children, we stopped at Wal-Mart and I bought a week's worth of groceries for $100. We stayed at Pop Century (and we didn't care - it was Disney!) where we only played in the kiddie pool and slept.

Our smartest decision was packing a microwave and ice chest, and eating in the room. There was no way, after a day of being in a park, tired, hungry and dirty, that we would have taken the kids back out for a full service meal, even if it had been free. We ate and fell into bed, every night. That $100 included food, drinks, snacks for the park, plates, bowls, utensils, and liquor for 5 days. We did eat at the Castle one evening with the Fairy Godmother. The 4 of us for $130. My kids were ages 4 & 2, so I don't think the 2 year old counted. That was our big splurge and the food wasn't that good.

We packed a soft sided cooler every day. It was juice boxes, bottled water, peanut butter crackers, grapes, bananas, and one day, microwave popcorn. We were inspected and told to have a great day. No problem bringing it in the park. We went back to the room to nap and have a late lunch.

If someone is new to Disney, they're probably happy to be over stimulated in one park per day. We certainly were. I'm not convinced that we'll do a park hopper next time either.

Please realize that you go so often that you are a bit immune to the magic. You have a great job. There's far more to be appreciated, and spend time on, than eating or being choosy about which park to attend in the morning vs. evening. Those things are all extras, and probably won't be appreciated by the first-timer anyway. Just try, once in a while, to consider those of us who mean it when we say "Budget."

Love this website!

Lesa”


For those of us who frequent WDW a lot, sometimes the ways we save money does not translate well to others.

In the first place, many of us go solo. That means we always try to stay at a value resort.

Secondly, since we are frequent visitors we all hold Annual Passports, which offer many opportunities to save money…room discounts…restaurant discounts….souvenir discounts…and so on.

Also, at least for me, I stick with the same airline and car rental agency every time and my loyalty is usually awarded with free flights and free days.

It all adds up…or I should say “adds down.”

cutting%20costs.jpg


For myself, my upcoming Mousefest trip includes a free flight to Orlando, a discounted rental car with a free day, a discounted room AP room rate at a value resort, and oh yes, through my Annual Passport I have a Disney Dining Experience discount card. All this plus I plan to use my Annual Passholder’s discount when I shop at the World of Disney in Downtown Disney.

One comment on Lesa’s note. I am not sure if guests are allowed to have microwaves in guest rooms so I would call the resort before lugging the oven to WDW.


Finally, I saved the best for last…from Tim…

“Just read your – ‘Magic your way’ article and I think if people look at a Disney vacation alone or not in comparison to other vacations, it may seem expensive. I took my family (wife, kids, 4, 2 and 9 months) in April 2008. We stayed at a moderate resort, purchased the deluxe dinning plan (which I am completely sold on by the way) and had all the bells and whistles added on. It was not a cheap trip – about $3,500 to $4,000 before flight, but what I discovered months later, was that 1) you can do it cheaper and 2) there isn’t much else out there that is even comparable!

Because we had such a great time, we began looking for other places to visit in 2009. All- inclusive resorts are extremely expensive for a family of 5, as we were looking at $8,000 to $10,000 just to ‘sit on a beach’ and eat the same food for seven days. Other family vacation spots (i.e. amusement park locations) couldn’t beat the amenities, food options, or even price! A local indoor water park up here in Canada for a one night stay was pricing at $400 a night! No food included. Even our ‘bargain’ vacation – renting a cottage for a week, although it didn’t have the transportation costs, by the time we paid the rental fee, bought groceries, rented boats and everything else, it wasn’t much cheaper than a value resort stay at Disney.

The end result… We’ve booked our Disney Vacation for November 2009. We took advantage of the ‘return trip’ discount, low attendance season and decided to stay at a value resort in a suite. We loved the Moderate resort, but having stayed at a value resort in my pre-kid days, didn’t see any deterioration to our FPM stats (fun per minute). Our kids, even at home, are much like their father – they get stir crazy if they are at home – so we don’t need the ‘luxury’ of a moderate resort, and quite frankly if the pool water is wet, then it meets our needs. We again opted for the deluxe dinning plan, park hopper etc, and even with paying for an extra kid (the ages will be 6, 4, and 2 this time) were able to keep the price under $3000. There is not a vacation out there that includes, hotel, admissions, food (and probably the largest variety of dinning experiences available in the world at any one resort) and entertainment for a family of five for that price. Disney is not only a great vacation and my personal favorite place to visit – it is also one of the cheapest. The only downside is trying to keep the plans secret for over a year – it’s especially hard when your kids ask if they can go to Disney every weekend…In about 370 days I’ll be able to say ‘sure – let’s go’.’

Basically, Tim is saying several basic things.

First, go with what works for you. Extra amenities are very nice but they should be looked at it terms of necessity. If you don’t need them then go with a different resort which may not have them but also offers a cheaper rate.

Secondly, look at all your line items for your vacation and carefully determine which of these line items can be tweaked to make the most out of your vacation dollar. For Tim and family the Disney Dining Plan makes sense…it may not for you and your family…but the point is to find what woks for you.

Lastly, and I’m glad Tim pointed this out…although everyone is quick to comment on the cost of a WDW vacation, if those same people looked closely and compared a WDW vacation to other type vacations they may find that the cost is quite comparable and that the quality of the vacation experience usually always falls in Disney’s column.

I think that the overall lesson learned here from all the folks who took the time to write is that it’s up to us to figure out how to do a WDW vacation in an affordable way.

That’s where WDW becomes our partner. We have options…we can customize our trip to fit our budget….we can create the Magic….our way.

About Mike's Mailbag

This page contains an archive of all entries posted to The View from Scopa Towers in the Mike's Mailbag category. They are listed from oldest to newest.

Special Disney Events is the next category.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Copyright © R.Y.I. Enterprises, LLC, All Rights Reserved, 1999-2009
Copyright © DWills, All Rights Reserved, 1996-1999
As to Disney artwork/properties: © Disney. All trademarks, service marks, and trade names are proprietary to Disney Enterprises, Inc., its subsidiary, affiliated and related companies, as the case may be.
AllEars®.Net, All Ears® Newsletter and any other properties owned by RYI Enterprises, LLC
are not affiliated with, authorized or endorsed by, or in any way officially connected with,
The Walt Disney Company, Disney Enterprises, Inc., or any of their affiliates.
Read more ABOUT US or ADVERTISE with us.
For official Disney information, visit http://www.disneyworld.com